The Hidden Costs That Eat Your Profit

Your marketplace fee isn't 15%. With holiday ad costs, it can be 30% or more. Why ACoS quietly eats seller profit, and how to know the number you can afford.

Anna Shtovbonko

11/19/20263 min read

Every holiday season, I see the same story. A seller has the best sales month of the year. Orders are coming in, GMV is growing, and everything looks great. Then January comes, they finally check their profit, and they find out they made almost nothing. Some of them even lost money.

What happened? In most cases, the answer is advertising.

Why ads get so expensive in the holidays

Pay-per-click campaigns work like an auction. On Google, Amazon, Walmart or eBay, sellers bid for the same clicks. During the holiday season, demand goes up and competition goes up with it. Everyone wants to sell as much as they can, so everyone pushes their ad budgets at the same time.

The result is simple: the price of every click goes up. You pay more for the same customer than you did in October.

And because sales are growing, many sellers don't notice. They see more orders and think the ads are working. But more sales don't always mean more profit.

The fee you don't see

Most sellers know their marketplace fee. On many categories it's around 15%. What they forget is that advertising sits on top of that fee.

If you pay a 15% marketplace fee and your advertising costs another 15% of sales, your real cost of selling is not 15%. It's 30%. Add shipping and returns, and it can be even higher.

Here is a simple example. You sell an item for $100:

  • Item cost: $50

  • Marketplace fee (15%): $15

  • Shipping: $10

Before ads, you make $25. That's a 25% margin.

Now add advertising. If your ACoS is 20%, you spend $20 on ads for every $100 of sales. Your profit drops to $5.

In the holidays, clicks get more expensive and your ACoS goes up to 30%. Now you spend $30 on ads, and you lose $5 on every sale. The more you sell, the more you lose.

The metric to watch: ACoS

ACoS means advertising cost of sales. It shows how much you spend on ads for every dollar of sales. It's the opposite of ROAS, and for profit it's the number I watch most closely.

Here is the rule I follow: every seller should know which ACoS they can afford. In the example above, the margin before ads is 25%. That means 25% is the break-even ACoS. Above that, you lose money on every sale. Your target should be well below it, so you still keep a real profit.

Once you know your number, you can manage it:

  • Monitor ACoS closely, especially during the holidays. Daily is not too often when competition is high.

  • Act when it goes out of range. Reconsider the strategy: adjust bids, budget or targeting, or pause the campaign. Don't wait until January to find out.

  • Look at each product separately. One item with a high margin can afford a higher ACoS. Another item with a small margin can't.

  • Judge your campaigns by profit, not by GMV. Big sales numbers feel good, but profit is what keeps your business alive.

Don't forget the other hidden costs

Advertising is the biggest surprise, but it's not the only one. Category fees are different for different products. Shipping costs go up in peak season. And returns come back after the holidays, in January, when the sales are already counted. Each of these takes a small piece of your margin, and together they can take all of it.

My advice

Before you push your ad budget this holiday season, do the math. Know your real margin, know your break-even ACoS, and set a limit you will not cross. Selling more is easy when you're willing to pay for it. Selling more and making money is the real goal.

Growth that loses money isn't growth. It's just a more expensive way to stay busy.

What ACoS do you aim for during the holidays? I'd love to hear how other sellers manage it.

Links

Contact

hello@cominger.com

© 2026. All rights reserved.