Who Wins the Search in the Age of AI?
Shoppers now start from a blank AI prompt, not Google or a marketplace search bar. What decides the AI's pick, and how sellers can be in the answer.
Anna Shtovbonko
11/6/20262 min read


Over the past few months I've been meeting with marketplace teams at Walmart, eBay and others, and I kept asking all of them the same question: who is going to win the search?
I don't mean the old search, where a shopper types a keyword and scrolls through pages of results. I mean the new kind. A shopper opens ChatGPT and asks, "I want to buy a Rolex as a gift for my husband. Can you find me one?" And instead of a page of listings, they get one answer. Maybe two or three. So who gets picked?
The "Blank Sheet"
I first heard this term at the recent Rithum conference. One of the speakers had picked it up at a Women in Commerce conference a month earlier and brought the idea with her. It stuck with me: more and more customers are now coming from a "blank sheet." They don't come from a Google search or a marketplace search bar anymore. They start with an empty AI prompt and a question, and the AI writes the answer for them. There's no storefront, no search results page, and no second page to fall back on.
For sellers, that changes everything. If you're not in the answer, you basically don't exist for that shopper. As e-commerce professionals, our job now is to figure out how to win the customer who comes from a blank sheet.
What Decides the AI's Pick
At the same conference, I also heard about research on how ChatGPT chooses which products and brands to recommend. The findings, roughly:
About half comes from Reddit. ChatGPT leans heavily on real conversations, reviews and recommendations people post there.
The other half comes from your performance and your Google presence. How visible and trusted you are in traditional search, and how well you actually perform, still matter a lot.
The exact split will vary and will keep changing, but the message is clear: AI pays attention to what real people say about you, and to how strong you already are online.
Why Most Sellers Aren't Ready
From my 10 years on the seller side, I can tell you that most business owners don't know how this works yet. Many are still focused only on keywords and marketplace ads. That's still important, but it's no longer the whole picture.
What I'd Do as a Seller
Build a real presence on Reddit. Not spam, but genuine participation. Answer questions in your category, share expertise, and encourage happy customers to talk about you.
Keep your Google metrics strong. Good content, fast pages, solid reviews and consistent product data still feed the AI.
Perform well on the marketplaces. Ratings, fast shipping, low return rates and competitive pricing build the trust signals AI looks for.
Think about how a shopper would ask the question. "Rolex as a gift for my husband" is a different question from "watch." Make sure your content answers the real question.
The Bottom Line
The search is moving from a list of results to a single answer. The sellers who win will be the ones people actually talk about, and who are strong where AI looks for proof.
I'll keep sharing what I learn from the marketplaces in our new News section. If you're a marketplace seller, follow along, and let me know: have you checked what ChatGPT says about your brand yet?
